DISCIPLES OF CLAUDE
Watchlist · thesis ledger
←Back to the drivers
Name detail

MP

−17.1% called side since lock · last close 46.14 (Oct 8) · high close 60.17 · low close 45.43 · 57 days since lock

Everything the four surfaces know about one instrument, on one page.

Locked lineages
LOCKED · Ethan · Verdict due December 2027 · 448 days out
The sovereign rare-earth proxy. The mechanism is convexity on geopolitics, not cash flow: every time neodymium exports tighten to squeeze American robotics and defense, Washington's shortest available lever is to fund this company harder — the book owns the hedge the government cannot avoid buying. MP Materials owns Mountain Pass in California, the only scaled rare-earth mining and processing operation in North America, and is building a magnet plant in Texas with federal subsidy behind it, built to supply the Pentagon and U.S. automakers — the only integrated American answer to a supply chain controlled elsewhere, at the stage that matters: magnets, not ore. When the next export squeeze comes, the response does not have to be invented; the asset, the customer and the funding channel already exist, and every squeeze makes them harder to cut. The expression is the common, sized as a hedge rather than a bet on the mine's own economics. The kill is registered in two parts: the geopolitical premise failing — export flows durably normalizing through mid-2027 while the magnet facility's federal offtake or subsidy support is cut or materially delayed — or the asset itself failing, a cut to Mountain Pass output guidance. Verdict due December 31, 2027.

−17.1% called side since lock · last close 46.14 (Oct 8) · high close 60.17 · low close 45.43 · 57 days since lock

Sealed on 2026-08-13 — the claim, what would kill it, and what counts as success are frozen on an outside receipt. Nothing here can be quietly edited.
Succeeds if: China does not durably normalize Nd/NdFeB export flows (a new restriction occurs, or normalization does not hold through 2027-06-30), OR the Texas magnet facility's government offtake/subsidy support is not cut or materially delayed — AND Mountain Pass output guidance is not cut — through the deadline.
Falsified if: China durably normalizes Nd/NdFeB export flows (no new restriction through 2027-06-30) AND Texas magnet facility government offtake/subsidy support is cut or materially delayed, or Mountain Pass output guidance is cut
Drivers Mandate constraint proposed Incentivized flow proposed
Verification details

Each fingerprint is a SHA-256 digest of the exact frozen text — a matching digest means the words you read are the words that were sealed.

Claim fingerprint (thesis_hash)7c7ca2c637286207…Falsifier fingerprint (falsifier_hash)847e48a8d03408ef…Success-test fingerprint (predicate_hash)420ce8d7ecd6184b…Outside custodyreceipt manual_operator · digest c673dc3726e15d04… · received
MERGED · Ethan · settled 2027-12-31
The Sovereign Rare-Earth Proxy. MP Materials owns the Mountain Pass mine in California — the only scaled rare-earth mining and processing operation in North America. They are actively building a heavily U.S.-government-subsidized NdFeB magnet manufacturing facility in Texas to supply the Pentagon and U.S. automakers. The Convexity: when China chokes off Neodymium exports to strangle U.S. Physical AI, the U.S. government hands MP a blank check to scale the magnet facility — the geopolitical hedge for Physical AI.

+17.3% called side since lock · last close 55.66 (Aug 13) · high close 55.66 · low close 47.49 · 9 days since lock · window closed Aug 13

Sealed on 2026-08-04, and since carried to its verdict — the words below are the words that were frozen; nothing was edited after the seal.
Succeeds if: China does not durably normalize Nd/NdFeB export flows (a new restriction occurs, or normalization does not hold through 2027-06-30), OR the Texas magnet facility's government offtake/subsidy support is not cut or materially delayed — AND Mountain Pass output guidance is not cut — through the deadline.
Falsified if: China durably normalizes Nd/NdFeB export flows (no new restriction through 2027-06-30) AND Texas magnet facility government offtake/subsidy support is cut or materially delayed, or Mountain Pass output guidance is cut
Drivers Mandate constraint proposed
Verification details

Each fingerprint is a SHA-256 digest of the exact frozen text — a matching digest means the words you read are the words that were sealed.

Claim fingerprint (thesis_hash)f5e77998d0565c74…Falsifier fingerprint (falsifier_hash)afd7d71d4cc73226…Success-test fingerprint (predicate_hash)bed19517fb14391b…Outside custodyreceipt manual_operator · digest 4a5dd5fc918b82be… · received
Cross-examination

Members file counter-evidence against a locked lineage; the desk owes a public answer by a deadline that renders here either way.

No member has filed counter-evidence against this name's locked lineages. The floor is open: `/thesis challenge MP <your counter-evidence>` from Slack.

COUNTER-EVIDENCE ≠ GRADE — a challenge never grades the thesis and never moves a score; it puts the desk on a public clock.
Edition assessments
Edition assessments

The room graded the proposition in each sealed edition — not a member.

2026-08-01 · NEW · LONG Backfilled edition hash 11a8fa4cad4120f7ad61f7af…
2026-08-08 · CARRY Backfilled erratum correcting an earlier row edition hash cjson-v1:29b5145ba5f2f06…
2026-08-08 · NO TEST Backfilled superseded by erratum — founder ruling D1 2026-09-20: standing thesis with no dated test grades CARRY edition hash cjson-v1:29b5145ba5f2f06…
2026-08-22 · CARRY Backfilled erratum correcting an earlier row edition hash 557bf5ef55f5d1fb8c7a88bf…
2026-08-22 · NO TEST Backfilled superseded by erratum — founder ruling D1 2026-09-20: standing thesis with no dated test grades CARRY edition hash 557bf5ef55f5d1fb8c7a88bf…
2026-08-29 · NO TEST Backfilled superseded by erratum — founder ruling D1 2026-09-20: standing thesis with no dated test grades CARRY edition hash 15bd0390467e559c74c076f3…
2026-08-29 · CARRY Backfilled erratum correcting an earlier row edition hash 15bd0390467e559c74c076f3…
2026-09-05 · CARRY Backfilled erratum correcting an earlier row edition hash 3ad7e3fa56cf10ecb514d9f1…
2026-09-05 · NO TEST Backfilled superseded by erratum — founder ruling D1 2026-09-20: standing thesis with no dated test grades CARRY edition hash 3ad7e3fa56cf10ecb514d9f1…
2026-09-12 · CARRY Backfilled edition hash 6271a4889f18e60066663572…
2026-09-19 · CARRY Backfilled edition hash 4f554e02dd2769ad9cd297aa…
2026-10-03 · CARRY Backfilled edition hash 6cbb3f12f574ec962d2274d6…
This week · 0 events

No recorded events

Explore this week →

Coming up
Verdict deadline · Verdict due December 2027 · 448 days out

No scheduled market events on the calendar window for this name.

Arbiters
Arbitersdeadline verdict: export-flow / offtake-subsidy / output-guidance check · 2027-12-31 · China export-policy record + MP Materials guidance/issuer disclosures · China durably normalizes Nd/NdFeB export flows (no new restriction through 2027-06-30) AND Texas magnet facility government offtake/subsidy support is cut or materially delayed, or Mountain Pass output guidance is cut · 0/2deadline verdict: export-flow / offtake-subsidy / output-guidance check · 2027-12-31 · China export-policy record + MP Materials guidance/issuer disclosures · China durably normalizes Nd/NdFeB export flows (no new restriction through 2027-06-30) AND Texas magnet facility government offtake/subsidy support is cut or materially delayed, or Mountain Pass output guidance is cut · 0/2
Fresh tape
Fresh tape
Oct 1 · Analyst action · Outperform to Outperform (Baird)
Sep 30 · Insider filing · 740 shares

Scheduled prints are context, never evidence — nothing here grades a thesis.

Tape
Tape

+5.2% since added to list · 2026-08-03 → 2026-10-08

2026-10-08 · 46.14

21/47 sessions with call — agreement, not judgment.

Newest sessions −1.0MP · 2026-09-25
close -0.95% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
edition week of 2026-10-03 — sealed
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
−4.9MP · 2026-09-28
close -4.87% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
edition week of 2026-10-03 — sealed
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
−2.2MP · 2026-09-29
close -2.20% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
edition week of 2026-10-03 — sealed
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
+4.1MP · 2026-09-30
close 4.09% — with call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
edition week of 2026-10-03 — sealed
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
−2.5MP · 2026-10-01
close -2.54% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
edition week of 2026-10-03 — sealed
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
+1.9MP · 2026-10-02
close 1.91% — with call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
edition week of 2026-10-03 — sealed
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
−0.3MP · 2026-10-05
close -0.28% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
+3.6MP · 2026-10-06
close 3.61% — with call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
−4.6MP · 2026-10-07
close -4.57% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.
−0.4MP · 2026-10-08
close -0.37% — against call
called side: LONG since 2026-08-13
Tape agreement only. TAPE ≠ VERDICT.

Daily close-to-close returns · Financial Modeling Prep end-of-day closes, automated daily ingest · newest session 2026-10-08.

TAPE ≠ VERDICT — tape agreement never grades a proposition and never derives an assessment.
Timeline lane
Timeline lane
LOCK-DEADLINET−448dmust meet its test by 2027-12-31
ARBITERT−448ddeadline verdict: export-flow / offtake-subsidy / output-guidance check · China export-policy record + MP Materials guidance/issuer disclosures
ARBITERT−448ddeadline verdict: export-flow / offtake-subsidy / output-guidance check · China export-policy record + MP Materials guidance/issuer disclosures

Full lane on the time axis

Identity
Identity
Canonical tickerMPFirst seen edition2026-07-30Registry stateactive
2026-07-30 → open · MP seeded from registry canonical_ticker — operator/MCP 2026-08-04 (open window; mechanical derivation, §ONTOLOGY: registry owns symbol history)
Divergence
Divergence

No divergence between the editorial and resolution layers on this name.

Open stacks

Held in 0 of 0 open member stacks.

The stacks hold the full record — stances are addresses, never advice.